The Football Association has recently announced a significant change to the format of the FA Cup, with replays being scrapped starting from the 2024-25 season. This decision has sparked mixed reactions within the football community.

The FA stated that the removal of FA Cup replays was a result of discussions that had been ongoing for over a year, with all parties ultimately agreeing that replays could not continue. The new format will see the competition played exclusively on weekends, with no replays from the first round onwards.

The EFL, however, has expressed dissatisfaction with the decision, claiming that the new format was agreed upon solely between the Premier League and the FA without proper consultation with all stakeholders. They argue that clubs, especially those lower down the football pyramid, will be marginalized as a result.

Various figures in the football world have also voiced their opinions on the matter. Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s deputy spokesperson highlighted the importance of ‘David and Goliath’ fixtures and the financial significance of replays for smaller clubs. On the other hand, Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer criticized the move, stating that replays are a crucial part of the FA Cup tradition.

Clubs from the EFL and lower leagues have strongly opposed the decision, emphasizing the impact it will have on their revenue streams. Exeter and Notts County, both former winners of the FA Cup, have condemned the change and called for a suspension of the new format until a comprehensive consultation with all stakeholders is conducted.

As the footballing world grapples with this shift in one of its most historic competitions, the debate over the removal of FA Cup replays continues to divide opinions and raise questions about the future of the tournament.