Crystal Palace are facing a familiar problem as they navigate a goalkeeper battle between Dean Henderson and Sam Johnstone, both vying to be Roy Hodgson’s top choice. The situation mirrors Arsenal’s challenge this season with David Raya and Aaron Ramsdale, highlighting the difficulty of managing two goalkeepers competing for the No. 1 position.
Henderson, who arrived last summer for £20 million, is poised to start against Arsenal on Saturday, having performed well since replacing Johnstone following the latter’s calf injury last month. While Hodgson has hinted that the No. 1 spot belongs to Henderson, Johnstone’s return to fitness presents a compelling case, as he performed admirably before his injury.
Not only do Henderson and Johnstone seek to secure the starting position at Palace, but they also aim to enhance their chances of making the England squad for Euro 2024, emphasizing the significance of regular playing time for both goalkeepers.
The situation poses a unique and challenging dilemma for Hodgson, who faces scrutiny as Palace grapple with ongoing struggles. With just one victory in 12 games since October, Palace finds themselves nervously positioned five points above the relegation zone. The pressure on Hodgson intensified after chants of discontent during their recent 1-0 FA Cup defeat at Everton.
If Henderson starts in goal on Saturday, he anticipates a demanding match against an Arsenal side seeking to rebound after a setback prior to their winter break. With Johnstone waiting in the wings, all eyes will be on the goalkeeping situation at Palace.
Discussing the predicament, Hodgson acknowledged the challenge of managing two quality goalkeepers, expressing uncertainty about retaining both players at Selhurst Park beyond the summer. The club faces the decision of persuading both keepers to stay or acknowledging the impracticality of having two England goalkeepers vying for a weekly starting role.
As the situation unfolds, it will be the responsibility of sporting director Dougie Freedman and chairman Steve Parish to address this complex scenario and make a decision regarding the goalkeeping dilemma at Crystal Palace.
