Apple has made significant strides in the realm of digital security with the introduction of its Passwords app in the latest updates for iOS 18, iPadOS 18, and macOS Sequoia. For many users, this development has sparked interest in transitioning from established third-party password managers like 1Password to Apple’s native solution. However, despite its potential, the Apple Passwords app currently lacks several essential features that are crucial for a seamless user experience.
For years, 1Password has been a preferred choice for many, including those who have longed for a more integrated password management solution from Apple. While Apple previously offered a rudimentary password manager embedded within the Settings app, it did not provide the user-friendly experience that many sought. With the launch of the dedicated Passwords app, users are now presented with a more streamlined option for managing their passwords across Apple devices.
Despite the promising features of the Apple Passwords app, there is one glaring omission that prevents users from fully committing to the switch: the lack of support for credit cards. This functionality is crucial for users who frequently shop online and rely on their password manager to store and autofill payment information. In addition to credit card support, Apple Passwords also falls short in managing bank accounts, identification documents, and secure notes—features that have become standard in comprehensive password management solutions.
Interestingly, there are third-party applications that can bridge the gap left by Apple Passwords. These apps mimic the design and functionality of Apple’s offering while providing additional features that users have come to expect from a robust password manager. One such example is Proton Pass, which has gained traction among users looking for alternatives. Proton Pass allows users to store credit card information, but it too has limitations, particularly in its inability to autofill payment details in web browsers.
The transition from 1Password to Apple Passwords has proven to be relatively straightforward for password and two-factor authentication data. However, users have encountered challenges when attempting to import other types of sensitive information. Secure notes, IDs, and software licenses that are stored in 1Password do not seamlessly transfer to the Apple Passwords app. This limitation is a significant deterrent for users who have accumulated a wealth of information within their existing password manager.
While Apple Pay offers a convenient alternative for online transactions, its adoption is not universal among vendors. Users may find themselves in situations where they cannot utilize Apple Pay, making the absence of credit card support in Apple Passwords even more pronounced. Furthermore, while the Notes app on macOS provides a feature to lock notes for added security, it does not serve as a comprehensive solution for managing sensitive payment information.
The launch of the Apple Passwords app represents a noteworthy advancement in Apple’s efforts to enhance user security and convenience. However, for those who rely heavily on their password manager for more than just storing passwords, the current iteration of Apple’s offering may not yet meet all their needs. As Apple continues to develop its Passwords app, users are hopeful that future updates will include the essential features necessary to fully replace third-party solutions like 1Password.
In the evolving landscape of digital security, the demand for effective password management tools remains high. Users are increasingly seeking solutions that not only protect their data but also streamline their online experiences. As Apple navigates this competitive space, the enhancements made to the Passwords app will be crucial in determining its success among users who are weighing their options.
